You Asked for My Opinion. Did You Actually Want It?
I've been thinking about those meetings where someone says, with great enthusiasm, “We really want everyone to feel they can speak up.”
Lovely.
Then someone speaks up.
And suddenly the temperature in the room changes by about six degrees.
You know the sort of thing. A suggestion is met with a long silence. Somebody looks at the clock. The person chairing the meeting says, “That's an interesting perspective,” in a tone that suggests it is neither interesting nor welcome.
And everybody else makes a mental note.
I find this fascinating because organisations spend an extraordinary amount of time encouraging people to find their voice, but rather less time examining what happens when they use it.
We have staff surveys, listening exercises, engagement forums, anonymous feedback boxes and workshops on psychological safety.
Somewhere, somebody is probably designing a lanyard that says SPEAK UP.
But what are we actually prepared to hear?
I remember learning, quite early in my working life, that the words spoken in a room are only part of the conversation. There are the raised eyebrows, the exchanged glances, the little jokes afterwards. The sudden absence of invitations to meetings you previously attended.
People notice these things.
And they adjust.
The next time someone asks for honest feedback, they offer something safer. Perhaps a suggestion about the office temperature. Or the biscuits.
Nobody gets into trouble over biscuits. Usually.
The organisation then congratulates itself on having created an open culture because people are participating.
But participation is not necessarily honesty.
And silence isn't necessarily agreement.
One of the things I've come to believe about leadership is that you can learn an enormous amount about a person by watching how they respond when someone disagrees with them.
It's easy to welcome ideas that confirm what you already think. That's rather like inviting people to dinner and being delighted that everybody loves your cooking.
The real test comes when someone tells you the chicken is dry.
Do you become curious? Do you ask what might improve it? Or do you spend the next twenty minutes explaining how much effort went into preparing the meal?
Now, of course, not every opinion is correct. Some suggestions are impractical. Some criticism is unfair. And speaking up doesn't automatically entitle anyone to have their preferred outcome.
But there is a difference between disagreeing with somebody's view and making them regret expressing it.
That difference matters enormously.
Especially when we consider who already feels comfortable speaking in professional spaces.
Some people have spent their lives being encouraged to express opinions. They're accustomed to being listened to, even when they're wrong. Others have learnt to calculate the possible consequences before opening their mouths.
Will I sound difficult? Aggressive? Ungrateful? Too emotional? Not sufficiently confident? Will this be remembered when an opportunity comes along?
Those calculations don't happen equally for everybody.
And when a workplace relies on people being brave enough to challenge authority, it may be asking the greatest courage of those who have the least protection.
I've often said that people are novels. We meet them somewhere in the middle of a chapter and assume we understand the whole story.
That applies here too.
The colleague who says very little might have plenty to contribute. The person who asks an awkward question may care deeply about getting things right. And the employee who always agrees with you might simply have decided that disagreement is too expensive.
Imagine the information we're missing.
I don't think good leadership means agreeing with everybody. Goodness, can you imagine trying to run anything that way?
But I do think it means being able to hear something uncomfortable without immediately turning the discomfort into somebody else's problem.
Sometimes that requires asking a second question instead of delivering a quick rebuttal. Sometimes it means acknowledging that a decision has already been made rather than pretending to consult. And sometimes it means thanking someone for their honesty, even when you don't like what they've said.
Then behaving in a way that makes them believe you meant it.
Because people don't decide whether it's safe to speak by reading a policy. They decide by watching what happens to the last person who did.
So perhaps the next time we ask people to speak up, we should ask ourselves something first.
Are we inviting their opinions, or are we inviting their agreement?
There's a rather important difference.



Comments